Macfie,
J.
(2001) Center for Developmental Science,
University of North Carolina, 100 East Franklin Street,
Chapel Hill, NC 27599-8115. The development of dissociation in maltreated preschool-aged
children. Development and Psychopathology, 13, 233-254 (2001)
ABSTRACT Dissociation reflects
disruptions in the integration of memories, perception,
and identity into a coherent sense of self, and
may develop following child maltreatment. The preschool
years were identified as an important period for
the development of dissociation. However, prior
research has not examined the development of dissociation
during this time. In order to address this gap,
evidence of dissociation in 45 maltreated children,
assessed for sexual abuse, physical abuse, and neglect,
was compared with dissociation in 33 nonmaltreated
children. Rather than depend on adult observer reports
of behavior, the study sought to gain an understanding
of dissociation from the child's own point of view.
Because self-reports have limitations with such
young children, a measure of dissociation evidenced
in children's narrative story-stem completions was
utilized. Maltreated children, especially physically
abused children and sexually abused children, demonstrated
more dissociation than did nonmaltreated children.
Moreover, during the preschool period maltreated
and nonmaltreated children followed different trajectories
such that dissociation increased for maltreated
children but did not do so for nonmaltreated children.
Findings suggest that although the self is normatively
integrated during the preschool period, it becomes
increasingly fragmented for some maltreated children.
Results are discussed in terms of cascading effects
of maltreatment throughout development, and the
importance of developmentally sensitive interventions.
Mangel,
F.S. et.al. (2000) An examination of bias in volunteer subject selection:
findings from an in-depth child abuse study Journal of Traumatic Stress = ISSN 0894-9867: Vol.
13 (2000), no. 1 (jan), pag. 77-88.
ABSTRACT Remarkably few
reported studies tested the assumption that a research
sample can be constructed which is representative
of the population of interest. In order to investigate
potential volunteer bias in abuse research, we utilized
a database assembled for an NIMH funded study investigating
the relationship among adolescent physical abuse,
suicidal behavior, and psychopathology. Extensive
information was available concerning the nonparticipant
pool from which this sample was assembled, allowing
for a comprehensive assessment of possible sample
bias. The volunteer sample of 99 abused families
who agreed to participate in our study was compared
on a large number of variables with a random sample
of 99 abused families who declined to participate.
Comparisons of the two groups did not support the
hypothesis that the non-participating families represented
a more dysfunctional population. The two groups
were far more similar to, than disparate from, each
other.
Markowitsch
HJ (2003) Physiological Psychology, University
of Bielefeld, D-33501, Bielefeld, Germany Psychogenic amnesia NeuroImage Volume 20, Supplement 1 , November 2003,
Pages S132-S138
ABSTRACT Time- and content-based
memory systems are briefly described so that their
importance for a refined analysis of memory disturbances
becomes evident. These memory systems are then related
to their brain instantiation, emphasizing that there
are limbic circuits for encoding different forms
of memories, largely cortical networks for memory
storage, and a combined temporofrontal network acting
to trigger information retrieval. The terms functional
amnesias and psychogenic amnesias are discussed
and their symptomatology is compared to that of
organic amnesias. The term "mnestic block syndrome"
is introduced and defined as a syndrome of its own.
Experimental data, obtained especially with functional
imaging methods, are presented to elucidate changes
in neural activation during functional amnesic states.
It is concluded that functional amnesic states,
confined to a patient's biography, can be triggered
by environmentally induced stress and trauma, leading
to lasting inability to retrieve autobiographical
events. Such an impairment may be identified at
the brain level using functional imaging techniques.
Markowitsch
HJ Kessler J, Weber-Luxenburger G, Van der Ven C, Albers
M, Heiss WD. (2000) Neuroimaging and behavioral correlates of recovery
from mnestic block syndrome and other cognitive deteriorations.
Neuropsychiatry Neuropsychol Behav Neurol 2000 Jan;13(1):60-6
ABSTRACT OBJECTIVE: We conducted
a follow-up study on a patient with enduring psychic
shock-induced cognitive impairment to study by neuropsychological
and functional imaging methods the degree of his
recovery process on the brain and cognitive levels.
BACKGROUND: Based on the assumption that trauma
and stress conditions can alter the functions of
the nervous systems, we report on a patient whom
we studied 2 and 12 months after he suffered "mnestic
block syndrome" and additional cognitive deterioration
symptoms. METHODS: We report on a patient studied
2 and 12 months after he suffered "mnestic block
syndrome" and additional cognitive deterioration
symptoms. Magnetic resonance imaging and fluorodeoxyglucose
positron emission tomography were used for neural
and detailed neuropsychological testing for cognitive
deficits. RESULTS: The patient initially manifested
severe intellectual decline, including severe anterograde
and retrograde amnesia. His symptoms were correlated
with major, although selective, reductions in his
brain metabolism (2-3 SD below those of controls).
Presently, he shows a normal brain metabolism and
has regained parts of his memory and many of his
other intellectual capabilities. Nevertheless, he
still has long-term memory impairments. CONCLUSIONS:
This case demonstrates a close relation between
brain metabolism and cognitive performance, with
major deficits of both at 2 months and major recovery
of both at 12 months after a shocking event. It
can serve as an example for possible stress-related
deteriorations in certain brain regions, which can
be partly corrected by psychotherapeutic interventions,
passing time, and favorable environmental conditions.
Martinez-Taboas
A, Bernal G (2000) Caribbean Center for Postgraduate
Studies, San Juan, Puerto Rico. Dissociation, psychopathology, and abusive experiences
in a nonclinical Latino university student group. Cultur Divers Ethni Minor Psychol 2000 Feb;6(1):32-41
ABSTRACT A variety of clinical
and experimental data suggest that many individuals
who report abusive and traumatic experiences also
report a wide array of dissociative and other psychopathological
symptoms. In this study, 198 Puerto Rican undergraduate
students participated in a study to examine the
possible relationship between different types of
traumatic experiences and the self-report of dissociative
experiences, depressive symptoms, and general psychopathology.
Another aspect of this study was the examination
of the psychometric properties of the Dissociative
Experiences Scale (DES) in a Latino sample. Results
supported the hypothesis that those individuals
who reported frequent and severe traumatic experiences
were also the most likely to experience psychological
malaise and scored higher on the DES. Of interest
was the finding that the psychometric characteristics
of the DES are consistent with those reported in
the United States and other countries. The authors
conclude that individuals with a marked history
of trauma and abuse are more likely to use dissociative
defenses as a coping response.
Marshall
GN, ,Orlando
M, Jaycox LH, Foy DW, Belzberg H. (2002) RAND Criminal Justice Program,
Santa Monica, California, USA. Development and validation of a modified version
of the Peritraumatic Dissociative Experiences Questionnaire. Psychol Assess 2002 Jun;14(2):123-34
ABSTRACT This article reports
results from 3 studies conducted to develop and
validate a modified version of the self-administered
form of the Peritraumatic Dissociative Experiences
Questionnaire (PDEQ; C. R. Marmar, D. S. Weiss,
& T. J. Metzler, 1997). The objective was to develop
an instrument suitable for use with persons from
diverse ethnic and socioeconomic backgrounds. In
Study 1, the original PDEQ was administered to a
small sample (N = 15) recruited from among men admitted
to the hospital for physical injuries stemming from
exposure to community violence. Results led to modifications
aimed at improving the utility of the instrument.
In Study 2, the modified PDEQ was subjected to structural
equation modeling and item response theory analyses
to assess its psychometric properties in a larger,
primarily male, sample of community violence survivors
(N = 284). In Study 3, the reliability and validity
of the modified instrument were further assessed
in a sample of female survivors of sexual assault
(N = 90). Results attest to the psychometric properties
as well as the reliability and validity of the modified
8-item PDEQ.
Marshall,
Randall D; Van der Kolk, Bessel A; Yehuda, Rachel. (2001)
Management and treatment of posttraumatic stress
disorder. Primary Psychiatry (ISSN: 1082-6319), v. 8, no.
8, pp. 75-81 (August 2001).
ABSTRACT Treatment of patients
with PTSD can be complicated in clinical practice.
The reasons why patients decide to seek professional
help vary. Patients with chronic PTSD usually do
not approach a physician with a clear understanding
that their symptoms and complaints are a direct
result of lasting effects of a traumatic event.
One of the major methods to engage a patient in
treatment is psychoeducation, which makes patients
aware of their condition and reach the point wbere
tbey want help and can be helped. There is probably
no single treatment strategy that can be applied
to all patients. Treatment has to be formulated
based on the patients' preferences, capacities,
and resources. Several psychotherapies and a number
of medications have shown efficacy in the treatment
of PTSD. The majority of experts recommend combination
treatment for the most severely ill patients, although
there is no systematic data to address tbis issue.
Marshall
Randall D, Franklin R. Schneier, Shu-Hsing Lin, H. Blair
Simpson, Donna Vermes, Michael Liebowitz (2000)
Childhood Trauma and Dissociative Symptoms in Panic
Disorder Am J Psychiatry 2000. 157:451-453
ABSTRACT : Childhood trauma
has been associated with increased risk for both
panic disorder and dissociative symptoms in adulthood.
The authors hypothesized that among individuals
with a primary diagnosis of panic disorder, those
experiencing depersonalization/derealization during
panic attacks would be more likely to have a history
of childhood trauma. METHOD: Rates of traumatic
events were compared between panic disorder patients
with (N=34) and without (N=40) prominent depersonalization/derealization
during panic attacks. Symptom severity in the two
groups was also examined. RESULTS: Contrary to the
authors hypothesis, no evidence was found
that depersonalization/derealization during panic
attacks was associated with childhood trauma. Minimal
differences in severity of illness were found between
patients with dissociative symptoms and those without
such symptoms. CONCLUSIONS: This finding is consistent
with a multifactorial model of dissociation. Factors
other than childhood trauma and general psychopathology
may underlie vulnerability to dissociative symptoms
in panic disorder
ABSTRACT Examined the relationship
between depersonalization induced by tetrahydrocannabinol
(THC), and regional brain activation. Cerebral blood
flow (CBF) was measured by means of positron emission
tomography (PET) in 59 normal right-handed volunteers
(mean age 31.8 yrs) before and following intravenous
infusions of THC. After THC, CBF showed a global
increase which was more marked in the right hemisphere,
frontal lobes, and anterior cingulate. Regression
analyses showed positive correlations between the
right frontal and anterior cingulate and depersonalization.
Linda
M. McLean, Ph.D., and Ruth Gallop, Ph.D. (2003)
Implications of Childhood Sexual Abuse for Adult
Borderline Personality Disorder and Complex Posttraumatic
Stress Disorder Am J Psychiatry 160:369-371, February 2003
ABSTRACT OBJECTIVE: This
study examined whether women with a history of early-onset
sexual abuse or those with late-onset sexual abuse
were more likely to meet diagnostic criteria for
both borderline personality disorder and complex
posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD). METHOD: The
Revised Diagnostic Interview for Borderlines and
the Trauma Assessment Package were administered
to 65 women from three outpatient clinics in a metropolitan
area. Thirty-eight subjects met criteria for early-onset
abuse, while 27 subjects met criteria for late-onset
abuse. RESULTS: The diagnoses of both borderline
personality disorder and complex PTSD were significantly
higher in women reporting early-onset abuse than
in those with late-onset abuse. The trauma variables
sexual abuse and paternal incest were significant
predictors of both diagnoses. CONCLUSIONS: In contrast
to those with comorbid diagnoses, some women with
a history of childhood sexual abuse may be extricated
from the diagnosis of borderline personality disorder
and subsumed under that of complex PTSD.
McNally,
Richard J.
(2004) The Science and Folklore of Traumatic Amnesia Clinical Psychology: Science and Practice V11 N1,
2004.
ABSTRACT Some clinical theorists
believe that certain experiences are so overwhelmingly
traumatic that many victims dissociate their memory
for the experience (Gleaves, Smith, Butler, &
Spiegel, this issue). Unfortunately, clinicians
who endorse this hypothesis often exhibit confusion
about the very studies they cite in support of it.
For example, they often misinterpret everyday forgetfulness
that develops after a trauma with an inability to
remember the trauma itself; they confuse organic
amnesia with traumatic amnesia; they confuse psychogenic
amnesia (massive non-organic retrograde amnesia
coupled with loss of personal identity) with (alleged)
inability to remember a traumatic event; and they
confuse not thinking about something (e.g., sexual
abuse) for a long period of time with an inability
to remember it (i.e., amnesia). The purpose of this
commentary is to dispel some of this confusion.
McNally,
Richard J. (2001) The cognitive psychology of repressed and recovered
memories of childhood sexual abuse: clinical implications.
Psychiatric Annals (ISSN: 0048-5713), v. 31, no.
8, pp. 509-514 (August 2001).
ABSTRACT Few controversies
in psychiatry have been as bitter as the one concerning
repressed and recovered memories of childhood sexual
abuse. Whereas some scholars doubt that traumatic
amnesia occurs at all, others believe it happens
often. Strikingly, this debate has been wholly unencumbered
by data on cognitive functioning in the very people
at the heart of the controversy: individuals who
report having repressed and recovered memories of
childhood sexual abuse. To fill this empirical gap,
our research team has conducted a series of studies
on four groups of women recruited from the community
via newspaper announcements: (1) those who believe
they were sexually abused as children, but who have
no memory for these events ("repressed" memory group);
(2) those who report having recalled long-forgotten
episodes of childhood sexual abuse ("recovered"
memory group); (3) those who report never having
forgotten their childhood sexual abuse ("continuous"
memory group); and (4) those who report never having
been sexually abused ("control" group). The twofold
purpose of this article is to summarize our findings
and to elucidate their implications for clinical
practice. [Text, p. 509]
McNally, Richard J; Clancy, Susan A; Schacter, Daniel L. (2001) Directed forgetting of trauma cues in adults reporting repressed or recovered
memories of childhood sexual abuse.
Journal of Abnormal Psychology. Vol 110(1) Feb 2001, 151-156
ABSTRACT An item-cuing directed forgetting task was used to investigate whether
women reporting repressed (n = 13) or recovered (n = 13) memories of
childhood sexual abuse (CSA) exhibit an avoidant encoding style (and
resultant impaired memory) for trauma cues relative to women reporting no
CSA experience (n = 15). All participants viewed intermixed trauma (e.g.,
molested), positive (e.g., confident), and categorized neutral (e.g.,
mailbox) words on a computer screen and were instructed either to remember
or to forget each word. The results provided no support for the hypothesis
that people reporting either repressed or recovered memories of CSA are
especially adept at forgetting words related to trauma. These groups
recalled words they were instructed to remember more often than words they
were instructed to forget regardless of whether they were trauma related.
McNally,
Richard J. and Susan A. Clancy, and Daniel L. Schacter
(2000) Cognitive Processing of Trauma Cues in Adults Reporting
Repressed, Recovered, or Continuous Memories of Childhood
Sexual Abuse Journal of Abnormal Psychology, 2000, Vol. 109,
No. 3, 355359,
ABSTRACT Psychologically
traumatized people exhibit delayed color naming
of trauma words in the emotional Stroop task. Four
groups of participants were asked to color name
positive words, neutral words, and trauma words;
these groups included 15 women who believed that
they harbored repressed memories of childhood sexual
abuse (CSA), 13 women who reported recovered memories
of CSA, 15 women who had never forgotten their CSA,
and 12 women who had never been abused. Repressed-memory
participants exhibited patterns of interference
indistinguishable from those of the nonabused control
group participants. Irrespective of group membership,
the severity of self-reported posttraumatic stress
disorder symptoms was the only significant predictor
of trauma-related interference, r(48) = .30, p
Meares
R (1999). Dept. of Psychological Medicine,
University of Sydney, Westmead Hospital, Australia.
The contribution of Hughlings Jackson to an understanding
of dissociation. Am J Psychiatry 1999 Dec;156(12):1850-5
ABSTRACT The author provides
a preliminary framework for a systematic and dynamic
understanding of dissociation through a consideration
of the theories of Hughlings Jackson. Jackson's
ideas are briefly reviewed. He saw the proper scientific
investigation of mental illness as an experimental
investigation of mind. Accordingly, his argument
begins with this fundamental concept. His views
of the brain-mind relationship and of mind, or self,
resemble modern conceptions. He viewed the self
as double and focused on those disruptions of the
self system which he called the "dreamy state."
This state involves an "uncoupling" of
normal consciousness, resulting in the loss of the
most recently developed forms of memory and of the
stream of consciousness. Dissociation is seen here
as analogous to the dreamy state. Jacksonian theory
predicts the main features of dissociation, i.e.,
constriction of consciousness, a particular form
of amnesia, disaggregation of perceptual phenomena,
depersonalization, derealization, and hallucinosis.
It leads to the view that dissociation can be seen,
in essence, as an uncoupling of consciousness.
Meares
R (1999). Dept. of Psychological Medicine,
University of Sydney, Westmead Hospital, Australia.
The "adualistic" representation of trauma:
on malignant internalization. Am J Psychother 1999 Summer;53(3):392-402
ABSTRACT This paper suggests
that traumatic memories are represented in a way
that is qualitatively different from nontraumatic
memories. The argument depends upon a concept of
self, derived from Hughlings Jackson and William
James, which is double, involving not only mental
life but reflection upon it. Trauma is seen as causing
an uncoupling, or dedoubling, of consciousness.
The traumatic diminishment of the subject-object
distinction in psychic life has several main effects.
First, there is a change in the form of consciousness
to a state which is focussed on the present and
on immediate stimuli. Secondly, the memory system
in which the traumatic events are recorded is nonepisodic,
lacking the reflective component. In this way, it
is unconscious. Thirdly, the traumatized-traumatizer
dyad is represented not as two persons in relation
but more nearly as a fused monad. This representation
is not integrated into the system of self as the
stream of consciousness but remains relatively sequestered.
This sequestration is "unstable," determining
rapidly oscillating, and opposite, forms of relatedness,
termed "reversals." Finally, in an "uncoupled"
state, the interpretation of the "meaning"
of the traumatic event is impaired. Its construction
is determined by affect.
Melchert,
T.P. (1999). Relations among childhood memory, a history of abuse,
dissociation, and repression. Journal of Interpersonal Violence, 14, 1172-1192.
ABSTRACT Investigated questions
regarding the relationships between a history of
child abuse, recovered abuse memories, childhood
memory in general, repression, and dissociation.
Of 560 college student Ss (mean age 19.14 yrs) who
completed a series of questionnaires, one quarter
reported a history of child abuse, and 18% of these
reported that they had a period when they lacked
memories of their abuse. These Ss endorsed a variety
of descriptions of their recovered memories, many
of which do not suggest a lack of conscious access
to the memories. General quality of childhood memory
was found to be unrelated to a history of abuse,
and most Ss, regardless of their abuse history,
reported recovering memories from their childhood
in general. Repressive personality traits were found
to be unrelated to recovering abuse memories, but
dissociative traits were found to be weakly associated
with recovering abuse memories.
Merckelbach
H, Muris P (2001) Department of Experimental Psychology,
Maastricht University, The Netherlands. The causal link between self-reported trauma and
dissociation: A critical review. Behaviour Research & Therapy. 2001 Mar Vol 39(3)
245-254
ABSTRACT Summarizes evidence
that cast doubts on the commonly voiced view that
the connection between self-reported trauma and
dissociation is a simple and robust one. It is argued
that: (1) the correlations between self-reported
traumatic experiences and dissociative symptoms
reported in the literature are, at best, modest;
(2) other factors may act as a 3rd variable in the
relationship between trauma and dissociation; and
(3) high scores on the Dissociative Experiences
Scale are accompanied by fantasy proneness, heightened
suggestibility, and susceptibility to pseudomemories.
The authors maintain that these correlates of dissociation
may promote a positive response bias to retrospective
self-report instruments of traumatic experiences.
Thus, the possibility that dissociation encourages
self-reported traumatic experiences rather than
vice versa merits investigation. It is concluded
that while attractive, simple models in which trauma
directly causes dissociation are unlikely to be
true.
Merckelbach
H, Rassin E, Muris P (2000) Department
of Experimental Psychology, Maastricht University, The
Netherlands. Dissociation, schizotypy, and
fantasy proneness in undergraduate students.
J Nerv Ment Dis 2000 Jul;188(7):428-31
ABSTRACT Previous research has noted a robust
correlation between dissociation and schizophrenia-like
symptoms. One way to interpret the relationship between
dissociation and schizotypy is to assume that it is
an artifact of fantasy proneness. In the present study,
152 undergraduates completed measures of dissociation,
schizotypy, and fantasy proneness. Dissociative tendencies
were found to be related to the full range of schizotypal
features. Regression analysis showed that schizotypy
still contributed to the prediction of dissociative
tendencies when variance related to fantasy proneness
was extracted. These results indicate that the close
connection between dissociation and schizotypy cannot
be interpreted in terms of an artifact produced by
fantasy proneness. Thus, the overlap between dissociation
and schizotypy warrants systematic study
Merrill
LL, Thomsen CJ, Gold SR, Milner JS (2001) Childhood abuse and premilitary sexual assault in
male Navy recruits. J Consult Clin Psychol 2001 Apr; 69(2):252-61 .
ABSTRACT Three samples of
male U.S. Navy recruits (N = 7,850) were surveyed
to determine whether a history of childhood physical
abuse (CPA) or childhood sexual abuse (CSA) was
predictive of premilitary rape of women and whether
these relationships were mediated by alcohol problems
and number of sex partners. In the 3 samples, 11.3%,
11.6%, and 9.9% of men reported committing premilitary
rape. When demographic factors were controlled for,
both CPA and CSA were independently and additively
predictive of rape in each sample, with men who
experienced both forms of abuse showing the highest
risk of committing rape. Additional analyses revealed
that alcohol problems and number of sex partners
significantly mediated the relationship between
childhood abuse (CPA and CSA) and rape perpetration.
Middleton
W, Butler J (1998) Dissociative
Disorders Unit, Belmont Private Hospital, Carina, Queensland,
Australia. Dissociative identity disorder:
an Australian series Aust N Z J Psychiatry
1998 Dec;32(6):794-804
ABSTRACT OBJECTIVE: Series of patients fulfilling
diagnostic criteria for Dissociative Identity Disorder
(DID), otherwise known as multiple personality disorder,
have particularly been reported on in North America
and increasingly in other countries. The present study
investigated the trauma and past treatment histories,
symptom profiles and dissociative phenomenology of
62 patients fulfilling diagnostic criteria for DID
seen in Brisbane (Queensland, Australia). METHOD:
From 1992, systematic assessments, including the Dissociative
Experience Scale and the Dissociative Disorders Interview
Schedule, were performed with a personal series of
57 patients with DID seen by one of the authors (WM)
and five patients seen by the second author (JB).
RESULTS: The histories of childhood trauma, the clinical
profiles and dissociative indices of these patients
closely approximate those described in series reported
in other countries. CONCLUSIONS: Patients fulfilling
diagnostic criteria for DID are regularly seen in
Australian inpatient and outpatient settings. The
dissociative symptomatology of the patients examined
in the present study represents a significant component
of a complex syndrome associated with a history of
severe ongoing developmental trauma dating from early
childhood.
Migdow,
Janet. (2003) The problem with pleasure Journal of Trauma and Dissociation (ISSN: 1529-9732),
v. 4, no. 1, pp. 5-25 (2003).
ABSTRACT Survivors of severe, chronic childhood
trauma, including those with dissociative disorders,
present for therapy with a wide range of symptomatology
that interferes with daily functioning. Fragmentation
and PTSD disrupt the capacity for integrated and satisfying
relationship development, which affects the social,
professional, and intimate lives of survivors. The
problem with pleasure -- that pleasurable stimuli
are often not experienced as such by survivors --
is generally not addressed in the literature. This
paper posits that clinical attention to the problem
with pleasure may significantly enhance therapy, engendering
substantial gains in resiliency that may allow some
survivors to more easily overcome the circumstances
of extreme neglect and abuse. This paper discusses
four primary domains that are affected and that have
implications for problems with pleasure: excitation
and hyperarousal states, the capacity for self-soothing
and the problem of numbing, skill development and
skill deficit, and core belief systems and attendant
script decisions. This paper posits that by understanding
more fully the interconnection between these capacities
and deficits, therapeutic work with survivors can
be enhanced, with greater engagement of their resiliency,
and hastening their recovery through the restoration
of pleasure.
Milchman,
Madelyn Simring. (2003) "Implicit memory"
cannot explain dissociated traumatic memory: a theoretical
critique. Journal of Trauma and Dissociation
(ISSN: 1529-9732), v. 4, no. 1, pp. 27-49 (2003).
ABSTRACT Similarities between implicit memories
and unprocessed traumatic memories have led traumatologists
to equate them. Both have "physicality": They are
grounded in the body rather than narrative, being
retrieved in sensations, motor responses, affects,
ego states, and images. Sheltered from the cognitive
processes that use language to alter memories, they
remain stable over time, unconscious, and dependent
on specific retrieval cues that replicate part of
the original event. Nevertheless, if dissociation
produces unprocessed traumatic memories whereas association
produces implicit memories, how can they be identical?
I argue that they differ in the causal mechanisms
and unconscious strategies that the self uses to process
their physicality. I hypothesize that unprocessed
traumatic memories change over time if the self integrates
their physicality into its central goals and meanings,
its core, making them less similar to implicit memories
and more similar to normal event memories. I propose
a new concept, "self-embodied memories" -- related
to concepts developed by Elin and Glenberg -- that,
like the concept of implicit memory, captures memory's
physicality but also relates it to the self's processing
strategies. A clinical vignette illustrates changes
in a child's unprocessed traumatic memory as it became
integrated with her sense of self. KEY WORDS: traumatic
memory, implicit memory, embodied self memory, dissociation,
unconscious, self-integration, encoding-specificity,
accuracy
Milivojevic,
L. (1999) Complexity of therapist's feelings
in the work with war-traumatized patients Croatian
Medical Journal = ISSN 0353-9504: Vol. 40 (1999), no.
4 (dec), pag. 503-507.
ABSTRACT AIM: To present the complexity of
therapist's feelings and emotions in the work with
war-traumatized persons and the importance of psychological
mechanisms taking place in such circumstances. METHODS:
The method of psychoanalytical psychotherapy was used,
adapted to the work with war-traumatized persons.
The therapy sessions were held once a week and lasted
for 50 minutes. The patients were given transference
interpretations differing from customary transference
interpretations. They were modified to provide support,
aiming at overcoming of the feelings overwhelming
each patient. RESULTS: The diversity of the therapist's
feelings amalgamated into countertransference was
one of the most important psychological mechanisms
in the therapy procedures, and served as an indicator
of the patient's feelings in the procedure. It was
related to the processes of projective identification
as a framework of the complex patient-therapist relationship
CONCLUSIN: In the work with a war-traumatized patient,
it is inevitable that the patient's feelings are partly
shared by the therapist through projective identification.
This can lead to the "burnout" syndrome
and threaten the boundaries of the therapist's psychological
system. The role of the therapist includes not only
knowledge but also the personal experience of work
on himself. Through the process of therapy and by
using interpretations as the powerful tool, the therapist
is capable to accept such traumatic feelings and help
the patient overcome them, but also to remain within
the framework of his role.
Miller,
A. The Dissociative Dance of Spouse Abuse.
(1998) Treating Abuse Today. 8(3):9-18.
ABSTRACT Cyclical spouse abusers, whether
male or female, appear to suffer from a specific type
of dissociative disorder that is related to a disturbance
of attachment. Similar to the classic story of Dr.
Jekyll and Mr. Hyde, the disorder is sufficiently
common to be designated as a dissociative disorder
in its own right. The partner of the spouse abuser
appears to develop a parallel dissociative process,
developing chains of state- dependent memory for the
different phases of the domestic abuse cycle. This
dissociative process helps both partners stay in the
relationship, while leaving might be the best course
of action. This "dissociative dance" facilitates
the formation of dissociative splits in their children,
enhancing the likelihood that they will be either
victims or perpetrators of domestic violence. The
article explains how the dissociation theory is manifested
throughout all phases of the abuse cycle, including
buildup, discharge, and post-discharge. Strategies
for helping battered spouses leave abusive relationships
are described. 15 references. (Author abstract modified)
Modestin J, Erni T.
,
(2004) Testing the dissociative taxon. Psychiatry Res. 2004 Apr 15;126(1):77-82.
ABSTRACT A dissociative taxon has been proposed by Waller et al. (1996) to help identify individuals experiencing pathological dissociation. We studied the frequency of taxon membership and tested its validity. A total of 276 students and 204 psychiatric inpatients completed the Dissociative Experiences Scale (DES). In patients with higher DES ratings, the Dissociative Disorders Interview Schedule was administered. Taxon classification applied to 2.9% of non-patients and to 12.7% of patients. No statistically significant relationship was found between taxon membership and the clinical diagnosis of a dissociative disorder. Taxon membership indicates a higher frequency of dissociative experiences but cannot be equated with the presence of a dissociative disorder.
Modestin
J ,
Lotscher K, Erni T. (2002) Dissociative experiences
and their correlates in young non-patients.
Psychiatric University Hospital Zurich, Switzerland. Psychol Psychother 2002 Mar;75(Pt 1):53-64
ABSTRACT The relationship between dissociation
and some of its potential correlates and antecedents
was explored. Young medical students (N = 276) completed
the Dissociative Experiences Scale (DES), Parental
Bonding Instrument (PBI), 20-item Toronto Alexithymia
Scale (TAS-20) and Munich Personality Test (MPT).
The findings indicate that both personality characteristics
(such as alexithymia and neuroticism) and, to a modest
degree, environmental factors in terms of the lack
of parental care contribute to the dissociation variance.
Moulds, Michelle L; Bryant, Richard A. (2002) Directed forgetting in acute stress
disorder..
Journal of Abnormal Psychology. Vol 111(1) Feb 2002, 175-179
ABSTRACT The rationale underpinning the diagnosis of acute stress disorder is that
cognitive mechanisms result in avoidant processing of aversive experiences.
This study investigated acutely traumatized participants with either acute
stress disorder (ASD; n=15) or no ASD (n=14) and nontraumatized comparison
participants (n=16). Participants were administered intermixed
presentations on a computer screen of positive, neutral, and trauma-related
words that were followed by instructions to either remember or forget each
word. On a subsequent recall test, ASD participants displayed poorer recall
of to-be-forgotten trauma-related words than did non-ASD participants.
Severity of psychopathology was negatively correlated with to-be-remembered
positive words. These findings are consistent with the proposal that people
who develop ASD display an aptitude for superior forgetting of aversive
material.
Morgan, Charles
A., M.D., M.A., Gary Hazlett, Maj., Psy.D.,
Sheila Wang, Ph.D., E. Greer Richardson, Jr., M.D., Paula
Schnurr, Ph.D. and Steven M. Southwick, M.D. - (2001)
Symptoms of Dissociation in Humans Experiencing
Acute, Uncontrollable Stress: A Prospective Investigation
.
Am J Psychiatry 158:1239-1247, August 2001
ABSTRACT OBJECTIVE: Peritraumatic dissociation
has been associated with subsequent development of
posttraumatic stress disorder, but supporting data
have been largely retrospective. The current study
was designed to assess the nature and prevalence of
dissociative symptoms in healthy humans experiencing
acute, uncontrollable stress during U.S. Army survival
training. METHOD: In study 1, 94 subjects completed
the Clinician-Administered Dissociative States Scale
after exposure to the stress of survival training.
In study 2, 59 subjects completed the Brief Trauma
Questionnaire before acute stress and the dissociative
states scale before and after acute stress. A randomly
selected group of subjects in study 2 completed a
health problems questionnaire after acute stress.
RESULTS: In study 1, 96% of subjects reported dissociative
symptoms in response to acute stress. Total scores,
as well as individual item scores, on the dissociation
scale were significantly lower in Special Forces soldiers
compared to general infantry troops. In study 2, 42%
of subjects reported dissociative symptoms before
stress and 96% reported them after acute stress. Dissociative
symptoms before and after stress were significantly
higher in individuals who reported a perceived threat
to life in the past. Forty-one percent of the variance
in reported health problems was accounted for by poststress
dissociation scores. Discussion: Symptoms of dissociation
were prevalent in healthy subjects exposed to high
stress. Stress-hardy individuals (Special Forces soldiers)
experienced fewer symptoms of dissociation, compared
to individuals who were less hardy. These data support
the idea that the nature of response to previously
experienced threatening events significantly determines
the nature of psychological and somatic response to
subsequent stress.
Muris,
Peter; Harald Merckelbach; Petra Korver; Cor Meesters
(2000) Department of Medical,
Clinical, and Experimental Psychology, Maastricht University,
The Netherlands Screening for Trauma in
Children and Adolescents: The Validity of the Traumatic
Stress Disorder Scale of the Screen for Child Anxiety
Related Emotional Disorders Journal of Clinical
Child Psychology, Volume: 29 Number: 3 Page: 406 -- 413
.
ABSTRACT Examined the validity of the Traumatic
Stress Disorder scale of the Screen for Child Anxiety
Related Emotional Disorders (SCARED), a recently developed
self-report questionnaire measuring Diagnostic and
Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (4th ed. [DSM-IV];
American Psychiatric Association, 1994) defined anxiety
disorders symptoms in children. A large sample of
normal schoolchildren (N = 996) ages 7 to 19 years
completed the SCARED. Children who scored high on
the SCARED Traumatic Stress Disorder scale (i.e.,
trauma group; n = 43) and children who scored low
on this scale (i.e., control group; n = 43) were then
interviewed about their most aversive life event.
In addition, children completed self-report questionnaires
of traumatic experiences and posttraumatic stress
disorder (PTSD) symptomatology. Results showed that
children in the trauma group more frequently reported
life events that independent judges considered to
be 'potentially traumatic' than did control children.
Furthermore, children in the trauma group reported
having experienced more traumatic incidents and had
higher scores on PTSD-related questionnaires compared
with control children. Moreover, trauma group children
more frequently fulfilled DSM-IV criteria for PTSD
than did control children. The results of this study
support the validity of the Traumatic Stress Disorder
scale of the SCARED.
Murray,
Lynne; Dana Sinclair; Peter Cooper; Pierre Ducournau;
Patricia Turner; Alan Stein (1999) The
Royal Free and University College Medical School and the
Tavistock Clinic, London, U.K. The Socioemotional
Development of 5-year-old Children of Postnatally Depressed
Mothers Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry
(1999), 40:1259-1271. Cambridge University Press.
ABSTRACT A community sample of depressed
and well mothers, recruited at 2 months postpartum
and assessed through to 18 months, was followed up
at 5 years. The quality of mother-child interactions
was assessed, as was the children's behavioural and
social adjustment, using maternal reports and observations
of child behaviour during free play at school. Several
aspects of child outcome were found to be associated
with postnatal depression, even when taking account
of current adverse circumstances (maternal depression
and parental conflict). These included the child's
behaviour with the mother, the presence of behavioural
disturbance at home, and the content and social patterning
of play at school. These associations with postnatal
depression were independent of the child's gender.
The child's relationship with the mother appeared
to be mediated by the quality of infant attachment
at 18 months. The mother's behaviour with her child
was more affected by current difficulties, in particular
by conflict with the child's father. Together these
findings suggest that, while maternal behaviour varies
with changing circumstances, exposure to maternal
depression in the early postpartum months may have
an enduring influence on child psychological adjustment.
Myers
WC, Monaco L (2000) Department
of Psychiatry, University of Florida, Gainesville 32610-0256,
USA. Anger experience, styles of anger
expression, sadistic personality disorder, and psychopathy
in juvenile sexual homicide offenders. J
Forensic Sci 2000 May;45(3):698-701
ABSTRACT Sexual homicide by juveniles is
a rare phenomenon, and information regarding the psychological
and behavioral characteristics of this group is limited.
No studies exist which have investigated anger experience
and styles of anger expression, and the relationship
between anger, sadistic personality disorder, and
psychopathy, in this type of youthful offender. These
areas were explored by evaluating 14 juvenile sexual
homicide offenders through clinical assessment, the
State-Trait Anger Expression Inventory (STAXI), the
Schedule for Nonadaptive and Adaptive Personality
(SNAP), the Revised Psychopathy Checklist (PCL-R),
and review of correctional records. Descriptive information
for the STAXI scales and internal consistency data
are presented. Trait Anger was significantly higher
than State Anger for the youth, but still comparable
to adolescent norms. The difference between Anger-In
and Anger-Out scale scores was not significant. Unexpectedly,
Anger Control scale scores were significantly higher
than Anger Out scale scores, clinically consistent
with efforts by some of these boys to resist sadistic
impulses. Those four (31%) participants who met criteria
for sadistic personality had significantly higher
Anger-Out scale scores than those without the disorder,
and were also higher on Trait Anger to a marginally
significant degree. Psychopathy was significantly
negatively associated with Anger Control. This study
is intended to contribute to the scant literature
on juvenile sexual homicide, and lends some support
to the validity and utility of sadistic personality
disorder as a diagnosis in younger forensic populations.
The findings did not support the contention that this
form of violence is necessarily an outgrowth of excessive
anger.